The series shocked viewers by unveiling two members of The A-Team. First, Nate, who turned out to be Linden James, the former True North boyfriend of Maya.
Second... Toby!!!
That's right, the character returned, reunited with Spencer, SLEPT WITH HER and then turned out to be one of the show's hooded sweatshirt-wearing villains.
Viewers are still reeling from the surprise, with Pretty Little Liars Season 3 set to resume in January. Until then, let the theories fly and sound off: Are you taken aback by Toby as an A-Team cohort?